Patterns with React Hooks & Context (compared to Redux)

Overview

• Redux is a popular way to manage state for React applications.

  • Typically a global store (read-only).

  • Store is mutated by dispatching actions.

  • Supports extracting data from the store from any nested component in the component tree (i.e., no prop drilling).

• Redux historically has had a lot of boilerplate and was a bit difficult to reason about.

  • More recently, much of this concern was largely mitigated by @reduxjs/toolkit (GitHub).

  • However, it still requires a fair amount of domain knowledge about how Redux works.

• Much of what you can do in Redux can also be done with (nearly) vanilla React hooks & context.

  • The below examples show 4 approaches to building the same UI behavior:

    • Basic Redux

    • Basic hooks + context

    • Hooks + context (with useReducer)

    • Hooks + context (with context selectors)

  • Caveat: performance and re-rendering

    • When a component subscribes to any property of a context value, that component will re-render even if that component doesn’t use any of the properties that may have actually changed. That is, an update to one component may trigger re-rendering of other components unintentionally, depending on how your components are structured.

    • The final example with context selectors solves for this “context re-rendering problem”.

Examples Code Repository

Each example below renders UI behavior that are functionally equivalent from a user’s perspective, but differ in terms of implementation pattern and re-rendering implications.

A random number is computed for each component cycle to more easily visualize when certain components get updated.

Open

Instructions

1. Clone https://github.com/adamstankiewicz/hooks-context-selectors

2. npm i in the root to install node_modules

3. npm start to run the application at http://localhost:8080

Examples

Redux Example

Source

• Because the example repo is using @edx/frontend-platform to bootstrap the MFE application, we may pass a Redux store to theAppProvider component in src/index.jsx

• The Redux store is defined ./src/examples/basic-redux/store.js

  • Adds a property/namespace counter to the store, controlled by a counter-specific reducer.

  • The reducer is defined in ./src/examples/basic-redux/data/counterSlice.js

    • Created with createSlice from @reduxjs/toolkit, which generates actions to mutate the data in the slice.

  • The reducer file also exports selector functions (e.g., selectCount1) to use with useSelector from react-redux.

  • Each counter component subscribes to the Redux store by extracting the respective count value using useSelector and handles decrement/increment clicks by dispatching (via useDispatch) an action.

  • When an action is dispatched, the reducer handles the action type and mutates the data existing in the store accordingly.

Basic Hooks + Context Example

Source

• Wraps the rendered route a React context provider where the current counter values are stored and accessed from any nested component under the context provider.

• The current values of each counter are stored in independent state variables, and passed through the (memoized) context value along with decrement/increment functions for each counter.

  • The decrement/increment functions simply call the state setters for each count variable.

• Both counters are subscribed to the same context, but read different values from the context.

Hooks + Context (with useReducer)

Source

• Wraps the rendered route a React context provider where the current counter values are stored and accessed from any nested component under the context provider.

• Rather than defining a count value for each counter in independent state variables, this example defines a reducer with an initial state containing both counters' initial value of 0. It also defines actions that may be dispatched to mutate each counter value.

• The current values for each counter as well as the reducer’s dispatch function are exposed in the context value for descendent components.

• Both counters are subscribed to the same context, but read different values from the context.

Hooks + Context (with context selectors)

Source

• Wraps the rendered route a React context provider where the current counter values are stored and accessed from any nested component under the context provider.

• As opposed to using useReducer in the provider, this example instead utilizes use-context-selector to create and read from the counter-related context for the route.

  • Github: https://github.com/dai-shi/use-context-selector

    • For details on how use-context-selector works behind-the-scenes, see

  • Expects the resulting value from React’s useState hook to be passed into the context provider’s value.

• Defines a custom React hook useCounterActions to return the relevant decrement/increment actions for each counter as helper for components to mutate the context value.

• Subscribes to only the relevant slice of the context value in each counter.